Unclassified · NSE: TATASTEEL
Tata Steel share analysis
Fair value, business quality, the case for and against, and the risks — computed by VestCall from reported data, updated 14 October 2026.
Tata Steel in one paragraph
Tata Steel (NSE: TATASTEEL) was trading at ₹175 on 14 October 2026. VestCall scores its business health 42/100 (weak). On valuation, the price sits in the “Valuation Premium” zone (₹166.14 and above) — above the modelled fair-value range. This is a reading of the evidence, not a buy or sell recommendation.
- Share price₹175
- Business health42/100
- Growth23/100
- Financial strength59/100
- Valuation36/100 · Fair
- Valuation zoneValuation Premium
- RiskHigh
Is Tata Steel overvalued or undervalued?
At ₹175, Tata Steel sits in VestCall’s “Valuation Premium” zone (₹166.14 and above): above the modelled fair-value range. Its valuation scores 36/100 (fair) against Unclassified peers. Zones describe where the price sits against modelled value; they are not an instruction to buy or sell.
| Valuation zone | Price band | What it means |
|---|---|---|
| Deeply Discounted | ₹147.74 – ₹158.53 | Furthest below the modelled fair-value range |
| Attractive Valuation | ₹158.53 – ₹160.67 | Below the modelled fair-value range |
| Fairly Valued | ₹160.67 – ₹166.14 | Inside the modelled fair-value range |
| Valuation Premium (current) | ₹166.14 and above | Above the modelled fair-value range |
The case for and against Tata Steel
What supports the case
- Shareholding Quality · 71/100.
What needs proof
- Growth · 26/100.
- Business Quality · 36/100.
- Capital Allocation · 41/100.
- Management Stability · 54/100.
- Financial Strength · 59/100.
Tata Steel key ratios
| Ratio | Tata Steel | Unclassified median |
|---|---|---|
| P/E | 6.84x | — |
| P/B | 0.37x | — |
| P/S | 0.21x | — |
| Return on equity (ROE) | 8.0% | — |
| Return on capital employed (ROCE) | 11.8% | — |
| Operating margin | 6.8% | — |
| Net margin | 4.7% | — |
| Current ratio | 0.52x | — |
Tata Steel growth
Growth scores 23/100, with a stable trend, measured Mar 2023 to Mar 2026.
| Measure | Reading |
|---|---|
| Revenue CAGR | -1.5% |
| Net profit CAGR | 10.5% |
| EPS CAGR | 6.5% |
| Revenue growth, latest year | 6.1% |
| Profit growth, latest year | 243.0% |
Tata Steel bull, base and bear case
Modelled annual return under three sets of stated assumptions over 5 years. These are model outputs, not a forecast or a promise of return.
| Scenario | Modelled CAGR | Weight | Assumption |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bear | −4.4% | 22% | Growth decelerates to -0.4% and the multiple de-rates toward the cohort's trough. |
| Base | +4.4% | 55% | Earnings compound near the measured 4.4% and the multiple drifts toward its quality-adjusted warranted level. |
| Bull | +10.9% | 23% | Growth holds at 7.4% and the market pays the full premium the measured quality supports. |
Risks to watch in Tata Steel
| Review trigger | Current | Threshold | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| Return on equity falls below the quality floor | 8.03% | below 15% | high · breached |
| Revenue growth falls below the thesis floor | -1.5% | below 8% | high · breached |
| Promoter holding drops materially | 32.95% | below 30.19%, 3 points under the Mar 2026 filing | high · armed |
| Price runs more than two sigma above its own trend | 175 | at or above 290.62 | medium · armed |
| Drawdown from the 52-week high exceeds tolerance | 20.86% | at or beyond 25% | low · armed |
| Leverage doubles from the level underwritten today | No leverage line in the balance sheet | unavailable | high · unmeasurable |
| Promoter pledge rises above tolerance | No pledge disclosed (the NSE filing for TATASTEEL could not be read either (nse_session_unavailable)) | above 10% | high · unmeasurable |
| Valuation reaches the top of its own cohort | No cohort multiple to rank against | at or above the 95th percentile | medium · unmeasurable |
An armed trigger is watched and has not fired; a breached one has.
How Tata Steel shares have traded
| Measure | Reading |
|---|---|
| 52-week range | ₹160.67 – ₹221.13 |
| Distance from 52-week high | −20.9% |
| Return, 3 months | −7.0% |
| Return, 12 months | +2.9% |
| Trend | Sideways |
| Annualised volatility | 27.9% |
| Deepest drawdown, 2 years | −32.9% |
Questions about Tata Steel shares
Is Tata Steel overvalued or undervalued?
At ₹175, Tata Steel sits in VestCall’s “Valuation Premium” zone (₹166.14 and above): above the modelled fair-value range. Its valuation scores 36/100 (fair) against Unclassified peers. Zones describe where the price sits against modelled value; they are not an instruction to buy or sell.
Is Tata Steel fundamentally strong?
VestCall scores Tata Steel’s business health 42/100 (weak). The strongest measured pillars are shareholding quality. The ones that need proof are growth and business quality. Each pillar is computed from reported financials, and a pillar whose inputs were not reported is excluded rather than scored as zero.
What is Tata Steel’s P/E ratio?
Tata Steel trades at a P/E of 6.84x, on VestCall’s latest read. A multiple only means something against the business it buys: the quality-adjusted fair value on this page weighs it against Tata Steel’s returns and growth.
What are the risks of investing in Tata Steel?
The review triggers VestCall watches for Tata Steel are: return on equity falls below the quality floor (roe below 15%); revenue growth falls below the thesis floor (revenue cagr below 8%); promoter holding drops materially (promoter holding below 30.19%, 3 points under the Mar 2026 filing). On the fundamentals, growth is the weakest measured pillar at 26/100. A trigger is a named condition that would change the reading, published so the case against the stock is as visible as the case for it.
Is this a recommendation to buy or sell Tata Steel?
No. VestCall states where Tata Steel’s price sits against modelled value, what supports the case and what would break it, with every figure sourced. It does not issue buy, sell or hold calls or price targets. Vestmind is not a SEBI-registered investment adviser or research analyst, and nothing on this page is personalised investment advice.
Compare with other companies in Metals and Mining
Read the full Tata Steel analysis
Every score opens into its signals, the valuation into its anchors and workings, and the statements are one click away. Free, no account needed.